Hard Shell vs Soft Side Suitcase: Which is better?

If you’re shopping for new luggage before the next holiday, you’ve probably landed on the same question most travelers ask: Is a hard suitcase or soft suitcase better?  The honest answer is it depends on how you pack, how you travel and personal preference. However, understanding the pros and cons of soft side vs hard shell suitcases can help you make your decision.

What is a Hard Shell Suitcase?

Before we answer is a hard or soft suitcase better,  let’s define what makes a suitcase a hard shell. A hard shell suitcase is typically made from polycarbonate, polypropylene, ABS plastic or aluminum, and has a solid outer shell. This makes it more durable and resistant to damage compared to soft shell luggage.

What is a Soft Side Suitcase?

A soft side suitcase uses fabric, typically nylon or polyester, stretched over a flexible internal frame. Instead of one solid shell, a soft suitcase is able to flex with pressure, which changes how it handles packing, storage and rough handling compared to a hard case.

Soft Side vs Hard Shell suitcase

Here’s how the two styles differ on factors which matter most when you’re choosing luggage.

These differences predominantly are true across most manufacturers though exact features can vary by brand and model. At a glance, hard shell suitcases are better overall for security and protection of your items whilst soft shell suitcases are better for flexibility and value.

Is a hard or soft suitcase better?

There’s no single winner here; it really depends on personal preference. Checking a bag, heading somewhere rainy or packing something fragile, then a hard-shell suitcase is likely to be the most suitable option since the rigid shell and water resistance will offer greater coverage. If you prefer having additional pockets for ease of organisation or need a bag which squeezes into an overhead cabin, then a soft suitcase is probably best. So when it comes to is a hard or soft suitcase is better, it’s about what fits how you travel.

Whatever you choose, look for a suitcase with a TSA-accepted lock, marked with the Travel Sentry Red Diamond symbol. Check out our brand partnerships, then get back to what matters: Enjoying your trip!

Soft side vs hard shell suitcase frequently asked questions

Is a hard or soft suitcase better for carry on?

Soft shell suitcases usually have the edge for carry-on since they can compress a little to fit into a tight overhead bin. Hard shell suitcases hold their exact shape, which is great for protecting fragile items but leaves less room to squeeze in that extra souvenir.

Which lasts longer, a hard shell or soft shell suitcase?

Due to their material, hard shell suitcases tend to hold up longer under repeated handling, resisting punctures and tears, which fabric luggage is more prone to over time. Soft shell suitcases can still last for years with careful use but tend to show wear sooner

Can I fit more in a hard or soft suitcase?

When it comes to fitting items, it depends on the size of the suitcase regardless of material. However, a soft shell suitcase may be better for more total items due to its flexible fabric, which allows you to stretch and overpack beyond the rigid limits.